Suspension of Disbelief
*SPOILER ALERT*
I have been watching a lot of horror movies recently, and I've run into a huge problem: none of them scare me. That's not meant as a humble-brag, I just genuinely find it difficult to get scared. It's not a problem of the movies being poor quality or the characters being impossible to empathize with. Instead, I have found the root of my problem to be my difficulty in suspending my disbelief.
I've watched The Witch, The Ring, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Conjuring, [REC], [REC] 2, [REC] 3, [REC] 4, Creep, The Tunnel, and V/H/S over the past two months, yet the only movie that managed to move me in any way was [REC].
The problem with many horror movies is that most of them rely on jump scares, and most of them are implausible. Jump scares are incredibly predictable. When I watch a horror movie, I go into it expecting jump scares. I find myself constantly thinking of what is going to pop out when someone enters a new room. The Ring did a good job of using jump scares by inserting them as flashbacks at random times, yet they fell short because they were either shown already or had no sound. I don't know about you, but simply seeing a picture of a dead person with a funny face doesn't really do anything for me. Even if I am not expecting it, flashing it on the screen with no abrasive sound to accompany it is more comedic than anything else.
Many of the movies that I watched had implausible plots. As someone that does not believe in the occult, all but The Texas Chainsaw Massacre were ruled out as plausible scenarios in the real world. Despite being founded in reality, I also found Texas Chainsaw to be an impossibility in today's society. The idea of a gas station selling human meat is incredibly hard to believe, as the government enforces harsh regulations on establishments that sell food, and I cannot see a health inspector allowing a gas station to sell untested meat.
What I've found after watching these movies is that I am very boring. I found all of these movies entertaining, yet I did not physically or emotionally respond to these movies in any negative way. The sole exception was [REC]. This movie was the best movie that I watched, and it was the only one that I thought had quality jump scares and an unnerving plot line. The movie being entirely in Spanish also helped to distract from other motifs and cliches of horror movies, such as bad acting and cheesy dialogue.
I hope that one day I will have an easier time of suspending my disbelief and being truly terrified by a movie, but I will continue watching movies of this genre in the meantime. Even though many of them are bad, horror movies can be quite entertaining.